11/2/2022 0 Comments Afternoon dice club tv tropes![]() These are reasonable issues that take a strong, out-of-universe position that places responsibility with the creator. I would say that it’s fair to criticize the unimaginativeness of almost every other Twi’lek character being designed as a scantily clad bombshell―even for variety’s sake if nothing else―and equally fair to praise the bucking of the trend with a character like Hera, whose more rugged, coverall appearance is more naturally conducive to the type of work she does than something more revealing. The appeal is, if not gone, then diminished.Īs far as the sexualization vs sexism discussion goes, I think it’s a multifaceted issue that requires an awareness of trends and context. Put her in a gown, however, and not only is she taking on a more feminine look, now she’s beautiful because she’s trying. She has the appeal of the “natural beauty,” who’s effortlessly attractive even in the plainest of clothes or without a trace of makeup. To paraphrase Rebels art director Kilian Plunkett, Hera is glamorous without trying to be glamorous. Both for the impracticality of such attire with the state of the Ghost and her role as it’s ready-in-an-instant pilot―something I would view as legitimate criticism of design form over character function―as well as for a more questionable issue you need look no further than her own introduction video to get an idea of. Were Hera to don evening wear, as you suggest, I certainly think there would be an influx of negativity. Afternoon dice club tv tropes tv#These are far more often considered feminine traits than what’s been attributed to Sabine, typically creating character profiles TV Tropes refers to as “The Chick” and the “Team Mom,” yet Hera is welcomed and Sabine taken with great wariness. She’s the heart of the group, the glue that keeps the crew of the Ghost together, so the sound bites say. Hera, on the other hand, is referred to as nurturing, and motherly. She’s called a tomboy, they include a clip of her actress noting that she is far more prissy than Sabine would ever be, and they repeatedly emphasize her Mandalorian heritage, weapons and explosives expertise, and a general sense of being an incredible badass. Mia: You know, the funny thing about the denouncements of Sabine as “too girly” is that the marketing department that put together her official reveal video made a very specific overall attempt to assure everyone that Sabine will absolutely not be “girly” in any way. How do you think people would react if Hera dressed in, say, evening gowns? How much wiggle room is there for people to oppose lightly-dressed female characters without crossing into sexism? And is that the same instinct that causes people to object to Sabine’s supposed “girliness”, or are those different issues in your eyes? Afternoon dice club tv tropes skin#I have a little trouble with this one, because I’m as tired as anyone of scantily-clad Twi’leks as a storytelling trope (one which we’ve commented on here before), but it’s very easy to conflate the cliché with the outfits themselves, and I don’t think the problem there is skin (even for a cartoon, frankly), so much as creator laziness. Mia, the thing that first jumps out at me is the fact that while lots of people rolled their eyes at Sabine for (apparently) being what you might call a girly-girl, they actually responded very well to Hera, except that what they were actually responding to, from a certain point of view, was her lack of obvious femininity-in other words, she was a female Twi’lek who didn’t run around in lingerie for once. ![]() This warranted a response of its own, I felt, but as someone who’s fully aware of the specter of “mansplaining”, I asked guest writer Mia Moretti, author of the aforelinked™ “race factor” piece, to join me for a discussion of these issues. ![]() Loosely speaking, it seemed as if people had certain preconceived ideas about what a good female character should be like, and were judging the females of Rebels one way or another less by their apparent merits and more by what they found “acceptable” for Star Wars-or even for popular fiction generally. Mike: In addition to the many, many larger conversations that sprung up in the wake of the reveal of Star Wars Rebels‘ main cast of characters last month, some of us here at Eleven-ThirtyEight noticed an odd undercurrent to people’s reactions to both Sabine and Hera well, maybe not odd, but unfortunate. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |